It’s a Long Way to Tipperary

“It’s a Long Way to Tipperary”

“It’s a Long Way to Tipperary” (or “It’s a Long, Long Way to Tipperary”) is a British music hall song first performed in 1912 by Jack Judge, and written by Judge and Harry Williams though the authorship of the song has long been disputed.

It was recorded in 1914 by Irish tenor John McCormack.

It became popular as a marching song among soldiers in the First World War and is remembered as a song of that war.

Welcoming signs in the referenced county of Tipperary, Ireland, humorously declare, “You’ve come a long way” in reference to the song.

Jack Judge’s parents were Irish, and his grandparents came from Tipperary. Judge met Harry Williams (Henry James Williams, 23 September 1873 – 21 February 1924) in Oldbury, Worcestershire at the Malt Shovel public house, where Williams’s brother Ben was the licensee.

Williams was severely disabled, having fallen down cellar steps as a child and badly broken both legs. He had developed a talent for writing verse and songs, and played the piano and mandolin, often in public.

Judge and Williams began a long-term writing partnership that resulted in 32 music hall songs published by Bert Feldman.

Many of the songs were composed by Williams and Judge at Williams’s home, The Plough Inn (later renamed The Tipperary Inn), in Balsall Common.

Because Judge could not read or write music, Williams taught them to Judge by ear.

The judge was a popular semi-professional performer in music halls. In January 1912, he was performing at the Grand Theatre in Stalybridge and accepted a 5-shilling bet that he could compose and sing a new song by the next night.

The following evening, 31 January, Judge performed “It’s a Long Way to Tipperary” for the first time, and it immediately became a great success.

The song was originally written and performed as a sentimental ballad, to be enjoyed by Irish expatriates living in London.

Judge sold the rights to the song to Bert Feldman in London, who agreed to publish it and other songs written by Judge with Williams.

Feldman published the song as “It’s a Long, Long Way to Tipperary” in October 1912, and promoted it as a march.

Feldman paid royalties to both Judge and Williams, but after Williams’ death in 1924, Judge claimed sole credit for writing the song, saying that he had agreed to Williams being co-credited as recompense for a debt that Judge owed.

However, Williams’ family showed that the tune and most of the lyrics to the song already existed in the form of a manuscript, “It’s A Long Way to Connemara”, co-written by Williams and Judge back in 1909, and Judge had used this, just changing some words, including changing “Connemara” to “Tipperary”.

Judge said: “I was the sole composer of ‘Tipperary’, and all other songs published in our names jointly.

They were all 95% my work, as Mr Williams made only slight alterations to the work he wrote down from my singing the compositions. 

He would write it down on music-lined paper and play it back, then I’d work on the music a little more …

I have sworn affidavits in my possession by Bert Feldman, the late Harry Williams and myself confirming that I am the composer …”.

In a 1933 interview, he added: “The words and music of the song were written in the Newmarket Tavern, Corporation Street, Stalybridge on 31st January 1912, during my engagement at the Grand Theatre after a bet had been made that a song could not be written and sung the next evening …

Harry was very good to me and used to assist me financially, and I made a promise to him that if I ever wrote a song and published it, I would put his name on the copies and share the proceeds with him.

Not only did I generously fulfil that promise, but I placed his name with mine on many more of my own published contributions. During Mr Williams’ lifetime (as far as I know) he never claimed to be the writer of the song …”.

Williams’s family campaigned in 2012 to have Harry Williams officially re-credited with the song, and shared their archives with the Imperial War Museums.

The family estate still receives royalties from the song.

Other claims
In 1917, Alice Smyth Burton Jay sued song publishers Chappell & Co. for $100,000, alleging she wrote the tune in 1908 for a song played at the Alaska–Yukon–Pacific Exposition promoting the Washington apple industry.

The chorus began “I’m on my way to Yakima”.

The court-appointed Victor Herbert to act as an expert advisor and dismissed the suit in 1920 since the authors of “Tipperary” had never been to Seattle and Victor Herbert testified the two songs were not similar enough to suggest plagiarism.

The song was originally written as a lament from an Irish worker in London, missing his homeland, before it became a popular soldiers’ marching song.

One of the most popular hits of the time, the song is atypical in that it is not a warlike song that incites the soldiers to glorious deeds.

Popular songs in previous wars (such as the Boer Wars) frequently did this.

In the First World War, however, the most popular songs, like this one and “Keep the Home Fires Burning”, concentrated on the longing for home.[citation needed]

Feldman persuaded Florrie Forde to perform the song in 1913, but she disliked it and dropped it from her act.

However, it became widely known.

During the First World War, Daily Mail correspondent George Curnock saw the Irish regiment the Connaught Rangers singing this song as they marched through Boulogne on 13 August 1914, and reported it on 18 August 1914.

The song was quickly picked up by other units of the British Army.

In November 1914, it was recorded by Irish tenor John McCormack, which helped its worldwide popularity. 

Other popular versions in the USA in 1915 were by the American Quartet, Prince’s Orchestra, and Albert Farrington.

The popularity of the song among soldiers, despite (or because of) its irreverent and non-military theme, was noted at the time and was contrasted with the military and patriotic songs favoured by enemy troops.

Commentators considered that the song’s appeal revealed characteristically British qualities of being cheerful in the face of hardship.

The Times suggested that “‘Tipperary’ may be less dignified, but it, and whatever else our soldiers may choose to sing will be dignified by their bravery, their gay patience, and their long-suffering kindness… We would rather have their deeds than all the German songs in the world.”

Recommended Posts